eeos @ 18:51 pm re: manipulation
Bro — Yes, that was my general gist about my thoughts on the manipulation blame game. Gold and everything golden was getting the crap pounded out of it last night and you mentioned ‘manipulation’ to me. I didn’t say that there wasn’t any manipulation across the board – of course there is from time to time on a relatively small scale. Sometimes (on rare occasions) people actually get caught and racked for it too.
However, on balance, I don’t subscribe to this manipulation thesis as an explanation for everything under the sun. Generally speaking, I think this rationalization often tends to reek of unreasonably suspicious behavior, sometimes to the point of being obsessive. I do think it is a cop out for the most part. It’s a convenient ’solution’ when things don’t happen the way someone thinks it ’should’. Afterwards, they often pull out the manipulation (race) card as the explanation instead of admitting they were wrong or that they don’t fully understand the mechanics of a particular move.
I think all to often what people attribute to ‘manipulation’ is actually the result of pervasive speculation. For example, I could say: look at the oil price over the past 5 years…up and up and up. Surely, someone has manipulated the price of oil — let’s pin it on GS for all the right reasons. When someone buys like crazy and talks their book the whole way up — is this manipulation? I’d say no, it may be gross speculation on their part, but I do not feel that it is outright manipulation. All one needs to do is look at the weekly CRB in any currency to see how far it’s come over the last 7 years. Did someone manipulate this massive index to kingdom come? No way… Was there lopsided speculation across the board…hell yeah.
Bottom line: this correction is simple playground justice — where something or someone gets out of control (like the grade school bully) and a bunch of rival kids band together and beat the daylight out him.